Under Dutch law, an employer cannot terminate an employee without a proper reason. Typically, termination requires filing a request for dissolution (Dutch: 'ontbindingsverzoek') with a judge, except in cases of urgent dismissal. A settlement agreement (vaststellingsovereenkomst) provides an alternative method to reach an outcome without going to court.
Understanding settlement agreements
A settlement agreement is a mutual agreement between employer and employee to terminate the employment contract. This avoids the need for filing a request for dissolution with a judge, and thus, the associated costs, such as hiring a lawyer. Employers often have a vested interest in negotiating a settlement agreement to save time and expenses.
Judicial Dissolution and Legal Requirements
When a judge reviews a request for dissolution, they will examine whether the statutory requirements (as listed in art. 7:669 of the Dutch Civil Code) for termination are met. If these requirements are not fulfilled, the judge will reject the request for dissolution. This legal scrutiny can make it challenging for employers to unilaterally terminate employment without a valid reason.
Valid Reasons and Negotiation Space
If your employer does not have a valid reason for termination, their ability to negotiate is limited. Often, a performance improvement plan (verbetertraject) comes before offering a settlement agreement. This plan helps the employer build a stronger case if they need to go to court later. The improvement plan is a backup for the employer if the settlement agreement negotiations fail.
Negociation space
Negotiation space often involves the following considerations:
Employer's Risk: If an employer takes the case to court, they must hope that their request for dissolution is successful and that their documentation is strong enough. If the judge denies the request, the employer is back to square one.
Additional Costs: Employers often incur additional costs when filing a request for dissolution, such as hiring a lawyer. Employers are also often required to pay a transition compensation (learn more here) if the agreement is dissolved by a judge. This financial aspect can motivate employers to settle.
Key Considerations
Assess your goals: Determine whether you want to challenge the termination in court or negotiate a favorable settlement.
Legal representation: It is strongly advised (seriously) to hire a lawyer to assist in the negotiation of a settlement agreement. A lawyer can ensure that your rights are protected and that the agreement contains all necessary provisions.
Protecting your rights: Ensure the settlement agreement includes provisions that safeguard your rights and do not waive your entitlement to statutory benefits.
Professional negociation: Having a skilled negotiator can relieve personal stress and lead to a better compensation. A good negoiciator understands the strengths and weaknesses of the employer's case by studying your file.
A few essential provisions the settlement agreement must include
Reason for termination: Clearly state the reason for termination, especially if it is at the employer's initiative. This is crucial for ensuring eligibility for unemployment benefits later.
Financial compensation: Specify the severance package, including any compensation for unused vacation days and other benefits.
Notice period: Ensure the agreement complies with the statutory notice period.
Reference Letter: Include a clause about the provision of a positive reference letter.
Non-Compete clause: Negotiate any non-compete clauses to avoid undue restrictions on future employment.
Waiver of claims: Carefully review any clauses that waive your right to bring future claims against the employer (Dutch: 'finale kwijting').
Conclusion
Navigating a settlement agreement requires a strategic approach and professional help. Hiring a lawyer ensures that your rights are protected and that you get a fair outcome. It is crucial to get legal advice and representation to manage this process effectively. A lawyer will guide you through the negotiation process, reduce personal stress, and make sure your interests are fully protected. Experience shows that having a skilled negotiator leads to a better result.
Comments